• Energy News Network
  • Energy News Network
  • Midwest
  • Southeast
  • Northeast
  • West
  • Opinion
  • Newsletters
    • Daily email digests
    • Centered.tech
  • Books
  • About
    • Code of Ethics
    • Staff
  • Donate
efficiency

State goals, policy help Massachusetts utilities take lead on energy efficiency

Written By Sarah ShemkusMarch 13, 2020
Photo By
urbanfeel / Flickr / Creative Commons

urbanfeel / Flickr / Creative Commons

The Massachusetts Statehouse in Boston.

Utilities and efficiency advocates credit the state’s regulatory environment for a strong showing in a recent ranking.

Ambitious state goals and well-designed financial incentives have helped Massachusetts’ two major electric utilities emerge as national leaders in energy efficiency programs.

National Grid and Eversource’s Massachusetts electric operations tied for first place on a scorecard released last month by the American Council for an Energy-Efficient Economy. Each utility earned 92% of the total possible points; the next highest scorer among the 52 utilities assessed was San Diego Gas and Electric, which earned 75%. 

“Massachusetts is definitely a state that others can look to for their experience and their best practices,” said Samantha Caputo, senior policy and research associate at Northeast Energy Efficiency Partnerships, a nonprofit that promotes energy efficiency.

The Massachusetts utilities’ high scores were driven by their program performance, which far outstripped that of other companies. National Grid saved an amount of electricity equal to 3.73% of sales and Eversource achieved 3.15% savings, the only two companies to exceed 3%. Only five utilities saved more than 2%.

Together, the two utilities saved 1.5 million megawatt-hours, an amount equal to the power used by more than 200,000 average Massachusetts homes in a year. 

“We signed up for the most aggressive goals in the country and we delivered on those goals,” said Chris Porter, director of customer energy management at National Grid.

The utilities agree that the regulatory environment in the state is a major reason they are able to achieve such significant savings.

In many states, utilities make money based on buying and selling electricity; in these cases, there is little incentive for utilities to implement energy efficiency programs, which would reduce their sales and thus their revenue. 

Massachusetts, however, is one of 19 states in which utilities’ revenue is “decoupled” from sales. Utilities make a set rate of return for the money they invest in energy delivery systems and processes, but they are not allowed to profit on the sale of the electricity itself. It’s essentially as if an online retailer were required to sell its product at cost, but was allowed to charge a carefully regulated fee for shipping. 

At the same time, Massachusetts law requires that, every three years, utilities develop a new set of plans and budgets for energy efficiency programs, working with an advisory council made up of stakeholders from environmental nonprofits, state agencies, consumer groups, end-users, and business associations. These three-year plans generally include incentives for utilities to meet their energy efficiency goals.

Together, these policies give the utilities strong motivation to up their energy efficiency efforts.

“It really starts with the fact that both [National] Grid and Eversource are put in a position to be successful by virtue of the policy and regulatory support within Massachusetts,” Porter said.

Together, National Grid and Eversource, along with natural gas utilities, administer Mass Save, a set of programs and incentives that encourages residents and businesses to become more energy efficient. Mass Save programs are funded by a small surcharge on consumers’ utility bills as well as revenue from the Regional Greenhouse Gas Initiative, a cap-and-trade system that aims to reduce emissions from electricity generation.

Perhaps the most significant of Mass Save’s offerings, Caputo said, is the home energy assessment: a free home visit by an energy efficiency specialist who will identify potential areas for savings, provide information about discounts and rebates on related products and services, and even replace all incandescent bulbs with LEDs.

“It’s a great way to bring people into the other incentives,” Caputo said. 

To reach their ambitious performance targets, the utilities have also looked for ways to move into traditionally underserved groups and provide resources to low and moderate-income households. Eversource, for example, has worked with social services agency Action for Boston Community Development to reach out to these groups and better design programs to serve them, said Tilak Subrahmanian, the utility’s vice president of energy efficiency.

“We continue to drill down on segment after segment to figure out how we address the needs,” Subrahmanian said. “We need to understand specifically what is their context, and how do we align our programs with these contexts instead of the other way around.”

The utilities have every intention of maintaining their leading performance in coming years. Both companies are expanding programs aimed at lowering the use of electricity during times of peak demand, when dirtier power plants are more likely to come online. Mass Save is also in the midst of a grant program that will fund projects building multifamily dwellings to Passive House performance standards, an approach that typically cuts energy use by 60% to 70% as compared to similarly sized, conventionally built structures.

Overall, Subrahmanian said, the key to energy efficiency success in Massachusetts is the state’s recognition that environmental progress and economic development can exist in harmony.

“They’re not mutually exclusive,” Subrahmanian said. “That framework and the ability to put dollars behind it is what enables us to do everything else.”

2020 ACEEE Utility Energy Efficiency Scorecard: Top 25

RankUtility
1 (tie)Eversource Massachusetts
1 (tie)National Grid Massachusetts
3San Diego Gas & Electric (California)
4Commonwealth Edison (ComEd) (Illinois)
5 (tie)Baltimore Gas & Electric (Maryland)
5 (tie) Pacific Gas & Electric (California)
7Los Angeles Department of Water & Power (California)
8DTE Electric (Michigan)
9 Portland General Electric (Oregon)
10Eversource Connecticut
11Consumers Energy (Michigan)
12Northern States Power (Xcel Minnesota)
13 (tie)National Grid New York
13 (tie)Southern California Edison
15Public Service Company of Colorado (Xcel Colorado)
16Ameren Illinois
17PECO (Pennsylvania)
18 (tie)Duke Energy Ohio
18 (tie)MidAmerican Energy (Iowa)
20Salt River Project (Arizona)
21 (tie)Entergy Arkansas
21 (tie)Ohio Power (AEP Ohio)
23 (tie)Ameren Missouri
23 (tie)Wisconsin Electric Power (We Energies)
23 (tie)Duke Energy Carolinas South Carolina

About Sarah Shemkus

Sarah Shemkus

Sarah is a longtime journalist who covers business, technology, sustainability, and the places they all meet. She has covered the workings of small-town government in New Hampshire, the doings of alleged swindlers and con men, and the minutiae of local food systems. Her work has appeared in the Guardian, the Boston Globe, TheAtlantic.com, Slate, and other publications. Sarah covers the state of Massachusetts.

  • More by Sarah

Related News

  • New Hampshire nears compromise on how to spend $5.2 million clean energy fund

    After years of delays, stakeholders say they are ready to move forward with spending plans for the money, which was set aside by Eversource when it divested its generation assets.

  • Connecticut regulator isn’t interested in utilities’ ‘excuses’ on power grid failures

    Since becoming chair of the state’s Public Utilities Regulatory Authority last year, Marissa Gillett has supercharged efforts around grid modernization.

  • In Cambridge, efficiency ‘concierge’ will help large buildings cut energy use

    The energy conservation program is a partnership between the Massachusetts city and utility company Eversource.

Comments are closed.

Subscribe to our newsletter

You can change which regions you're subscribed to by clicking the link in the footer of our emails.

Latest News

  • Senate confirms Granholm to lead Energy Department
  • Illinois Capitol
    Illinois energy bill proposes ‘green bank’ as national movement builds
  • Looking up from underneath a transmission tower.
    Critics fear investors’ push for profits could thwart other FirstEnergy priorities
  • A swing set stands alone in the Salton Sea.
    Will California’s desert be transformed into Lithium Valley?
  • Power plant smokestacks in the background; power lines in the foreground.
    As coal plants close, advocates want relief for Wisconsin ratepayers
  • Closeup of the HourCar logo on the back of a blue car.
    Minnesota car-share program seeks to boost EV access in diverse neighborhoods
  • Inside the Ohio Senate chamber from above.
    Ohio Republicans’ bill would force state agencies to reduce their rule books
  • An aerial view of downtown Lima, Ohio.
    Ohio refinery city joins coalition to support local clean energy transitions

More from the Energy News Network

  • Energy News Network
  • Midwest
  • Southeast
  • Northeast
  • West
  • About
  • Support

The Energy News Network is an editorially independent project of  
© Copyright 2021

  • Terms of Service
  • Privacy Policy

Built with the Largo WordPress Theme from the Institute for Nonprofit News.

Back to top ↑